Problem „zmiany modalności” w hipotezach pierwszeństwa gestów w ewolucji języka: w stronę hipotez multimodalnych
PDF (Polski)


language evolution
gestural protolanguage
modality transition problem
multimodal hypotheses



In our paper we review the gestural primacy hypotheses in language evolution, starting with the discussion of the historical advocates of this approach and concluding with the contemporary arguments, derived from empirical research in various fields of study. Assessing the strengths and weaknesses of the gestural scenarios we point to their main problem, namely their inability to account for the transition from a mainly visual to a mainly vocal modality (the so called “modality transition problem”). Subsequently, we discuss several potential solutions to this problem, and arrive at a conclusion that the most satisfying option is the multimodal perspective, which posits that language evolved as a bimodal system, with the vocal and visual modalities very closely integrated from the very early stages.

PDF (Polski)


Arbib Michael A. 2002. The Mirror System, Imitation, and the Evolution of Language. W Imitation in Animals and Artifacts, K. Dautenhahn, Ch. Nehaniv (red.). London: A Bradford Book.

Arbib Michael A. 2005. "From monkey–like action recognition to human language: an evolutionary framework for neurolinguistics". Behavioral and Brain Sciences 28 : 105–167.

Arbib Michael A. 2012. How the brain got language. Oxford University Press.

Armstrong David F., Sherman E. Wilcox. 2007. The gestural origin of language. Oxford University Press.

Armstrong David F., William C. Stokoe, Sherman E. Wilcox. 1995. Gesture and the nature of language. Cambridge University Press.

Bavelas Janet, Jennifer Gerwing, Chantelle Sutton, Danielle Prevost. 2008. "Gesturing on the telephone: Independent effects of dialogue and visibility". Journal of Memory and Language 58 : 495–520.

Bellugi Ursula, Edward S. Klima. 2001. Sign Language. W International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences vol. 21, N. Smelser, P. Baltes (red.), 14066–14071. Oxford: Elsevier Science Publishers.

Bickerton Derek. 1990. Language and species. University of Chicago Press.

Burling Robbins. 2005. The talking ape: How language evolved. Oxford University Press.

Campbell Lyle. 1998. Historical Linguistics: An Introduction. Edinburgh University Press.

Calvin William H. 1982. "Did throwing stones shape hominid brain evolution?" Ethology and Sociobiology 3 : 115–124.

Calvin William H. 1983. The throwing Madonna: Essays on the brain. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Calvin William H., Derek Bickerton. 2000. Lingua ex machine: reconciling Darwin and Chomsky with the human brain. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Carstairs-McCarthy Andrew. 1996. "Review of Armstrong, Stokoe i Wilcox ‘Gesture and the nature of language’". Lingua 99: 135–138.

Cashmore Lisa, Natalie Uomini, Amandine Chapelain. 2008. "The evolution of handedness in humans and great apes: a review and current issues". Journal of Anthropological Sciences 86 : 7–35

Corballis Michael C. 2002. From hand to mouth: The origins of language. Princeton University Press.

Corballis Michael C. 2003. "From mouth to hand: gesture, speech, and the evolution of right-handedness". Behavioral and Brain Sciences 26 (2) : 199–208.

Corina David P., Jyotsna Vaid, Ursula Bellugi. 1992. "The linguistic basis of left hemisphere specialization". Science 255 : 1258–1260.

Deacon Terrence W. 1997. The symbolic species: The coevolution of language and the brain. New York: W.W. Norton and Company/London: Penguin Press.

Dediu Dan, Stephen C. Levinson. 2013. "On the antiquity of language: the reinterpretation of Neandertal linguistic capacities and its consequences". Frontiers in Psychology 4 : 397.

Donald Merlin. 1991. Origins of the modern mind: Three stages in the evolution of culture and cognition. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Donald Merlin. 2001. A Mind So Rare. The Evolution of Human Consciousness. New York: Norton. Emery, N.J.

Dunbar Robin. 1998. Grooming, gossip and the evolution of language. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Ekman Paul, Wallace V. Friesen. 1969. "The repertoire of nonverbal behavior: Categories, origins, usage, and coding". Semiotica 1 : 49–98.

Emmorey Karen. 2002. Language, cognition, and brain: Insights from sign language research. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

Fadiga Luciano, Laila Craighero, Alessandro D’Ausilio. 2009. "Broca’s Area in language, action and music". Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1169 : 448–458.

Falk Dean. 2009. Finding our tongues: Mothers, infants and the origins of language. New York: Basic Books.

Fay Nicolas, Michael A. Arbib, Simon Garrod. 2013. "How to Bootstrap a Human Communication System". Cognitive Science 37 : 1356–1367.

Fisiak Jacek. 1985. Wstęp do współczesnych teorii lingwistycznych. Warszawa: WSiP.

Fitch William Tecumseh. 2010. The evolution of language. Cambridge University Press.

Fogassi Leonardo, Pier Francesco Ferrari. 2004. "Mirror neurons, gestures and language evolution". Interaction Studies 5 : 345–363.

Gardner R. Allen, Beatrice T. Gardner. 1969. "Teaching sign language to a chimpanzee". Science 165 : 664–672.

Gentilucci Maurizio, Michael C. Corballis. 2006. "From manual gesture to speech: A gradual transition". Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 30 : 949–960.

Goldin-Meadow Susan. 2003. Hearing Gesture: How Our Hands Helps Us Think. Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

Goldin-Meadow Susan. 2005. "What language creation in the manual modality tells us about the foundations of language". The Linguistic Review 22 : 199–225.

Goldin-Meadow Susan. 2008. Gesture, Speech, and Language. W Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on the Evolution of Language, A. Smith, K. Smith, R. Ferrer-i-Cancho (red.), 427–428. London: World Scientific.

Goldin-Meadow Susan. 2011. What modern-day gesture can tell us about language evolution. W The Oxford handbook of language evolution, M. Tallerman, K. R. Gibson (red.), 545–557. Oxford University Press.

Goldin-Meadow Susan, Wing-Chee So, Asli Özyürek, Carolyn Mylander. 2008. "The natural order of events: How speakers of different languages represent events nonverbally". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 105 : 9163–9168.

Gonseth Chloe, Anne Vilain, Coriandre Vilain. 2012. Ontogeny of two communicative tools: Distance encoding and multimodality in deictic pointing. W The Evolution of Language. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference (EVOLANG 9), T. Scott-Phillips, M. Tamariz, E. Cartmill, J. Hurford (red.), 150–157. New Jersey: World Scientific.

Harrison Rebecca. 2008. What can the study of handedness in nonhuman apes tell us about the evolution of language. W Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on the Evolution of Language, A. D. M. Smith, K. Smith, R. Ferrer-i-Cancho (red.), 431–432. London: World Scientific.

Hauser Marc D., Noam Chomsky, W. Tecumseh Fitch. 2002. "The faculty of language: What is it, who has it, and how did it evolve?" Science 298 : 1569–1579.

Hewes Gordon W. 1973. "Primate communication and the gestural origins of language". Current Anthropology 14 : 5–24.

Hewes Gordon W. 1981. Pointing and language. W The cognitive representation of speech, T. Myers, J. Laver, J. Andreson (red.), 263–269. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

Hewes Gordon W. 1996. A history of the study of language origins and the gestural primacy hypothesis. W Handbook of human symbolic evolution, A. Lock, C. R. Peters (red.), 571–595. Oxford University Press.

Hickok Gregory, Ursula Bellugi, Edward S. Klima. 1996. "The neurobiology of sign language and its implications for the neural basis of language". Nature 381 : 699–702.

Hobaiter Catherine, Richard W. Byrne. 2012. "Gesture use in consortship". Developments in Primate Gesture Research 6 : 129–146.

Hockett Charles F. 1960. "The Origin of Speech". Scientific American 203 : 88–96.

Hopkins William D. 2006. "Comparative and familial analysis of handedness in great apes". Psychological Bulletin 132 : 538.

Hurford James R. 2007. The origins of meaning. Language in the light of evolution. Oxford University Press.

Hutto Daniel D. 2008. First communions: Mimetic sharing without theory of mind. W The Shared Mind: Perspectives on intersubjectivity, J. Zlatev, T. Racine, C. Sinha, E. Itkonen (red.), 246–276. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing.

Iacoboni Marco, Roger P. Woods, Marcel Brass, Harold Bekkering, John C. Mazziotta, Giacomo Rizzolatti. 1999. "Cortical mechanisms of human imitation". Science 286 : 2526–2528.

Iverson Jana M., Susan Goldin-Meadow. 1997. "What communication got to do with it? Gesture in congenitally blind children". Developmental psychology 33 : 453–467.

Johansson Sverker. 2005. Origins of language. Constraints on hypothesis. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing.

Johansson Sverker. 2012. The case for Neanderthal language – how strong is it? W The Evolution of Language. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference (EVOLANG 9), T. Scott-Phillips, M. Tamariz, E. Cartmill, J. Hurford (red.), 173–180. New York: World Scientific.

Kendon Adam. 1991. "Some considerations for a theory of language origins". Man 26 : 199–221.

Kendon Adam. 2004. Gesture: Visible action as utterance. Cambridge University Press.

Kendon Adam. 2008. "Signs for Language Origins?" The Public Journal of Semiotics II (2) : 2–29.

Kendon Adam. 2011. "Some modern considerations for thinking about language evolution: A discussion of The Evolution of Language by Tecumseh Fitch". The Public Journal of Semiotics III (1) : 79–108.

Kenneally Christine. 2007. The first word. New York: Viking.

Kegl Judy, Ann Senghas, Marie Coppola. 1999. Creation through contact: Sign language emergence and sign language change in Nicaragua. W Language Creation and Language Change: Creolization, Diachrony, and Development, M. DeGraff (red.), 179–237. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Knecht Stefan, Bianca Dräger, Michael Deppe, Lars Bobe, Hubertus Lohmann, Agnes Flöel, Bernd E. Ringelstein, Henning Henningsen. 2000. "Handedness and hemispheric language dominance in healthy humans". Brain 123 : 2512–2518.

Knight Chris. 2000. Play as precursors of phonology and syntax. W The evolutionary emergence of language, Ch. Knight, M. Studdert-Kennedy, J. Hurford (red.), 99–119. Cambridge University Press.

Krauss Robert M., Yihsiu Chen, Rebecca F. Gottesman. 2000. Lexical gestures and lexical access: A process model. W Language and gesture, D. McNeill (red.), 261–283. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Liberman Alvin M., Franklin S. Cooper, Donald P. Shankweiler, Michael Studdert-Kennedy. 1967. "Perception of the speech code". Psychological review 74 : 431–461.

Liberman Alvin M., Ignatius G. Mattingly. 1985. "The motor theory of speech perception revisited". Cognition 21 : 1–36.

Liberman Alvin M., Doug H. Whalen. 2000. "On the relation of speech to language". Trends in cognitive sciences 4 : 187–196.

Lieberman Philip. 2003. Motor control, Speech, and the Evolution of Human Language. W Language Evolution, M. H. Christiansen, S. Kirby (red.), 255–271. New York: Oxford University Press.

MacNeilage Peter F. 1998. "The frame/content theory of the evolution of speech production". Behavioral and brain sciences 21 : 499–556.

MacNeilage Peter F. 2008. The Origin of Speech. Oxford University Press.

Maestripieri Dario. 2007. Gestural communication in three species of macaques (Macaca mulatta, M. nemestrina, M. arctoides): Use of signals in relation to dominance and social context. W Gestural Communication in Nonhuman and Human Primates, K. Liebal, C. Muller, S. Pika (red.), 53–68. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing.

McGurk Harry, John MacDonald. 1976. "Hearing lips and seeing voices". Nature 264 : 746–748.

McNeill David. 1992. What Gestures Reveal About Thought. The University of Chicago Press.

McNeill David. 2005. Gesture and Thought. The University of Chicago Press.

McNeill David. 2012. How Language Began: Gesture and Speech in Human Evolution. Cambridge University Press.

Meguerditchian Adrien, Hélène Cochet, Jacques Vauclair. 2011. From gesture to language: ontogenetic and phylogenetic perspectives on gestural communication and its cerebral lateralization. W Primate communication and human language: vocalisation, gestures, imitation and deixis in humans and non-humans, A. Vilain, J. Schwartz, Ch. Abry, J. Vauclair (red.), 89–118. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing.

Mithen Steven. 2005. The singing Neanderthals: The origins of music, language, mind and body. London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson.

Murata Akira, Luciano Fadiga, Leonardo Fogassi, Vittorio Gallese, Vassilis Raos, Giacomo Rizzolatti. 1997. "Object representation in the ventral premotor cortex (area F5) of the monkey". Journal of neurophysiology 78 (4) : 2226–30.

Niederhut Dillon. 2012. Gesture and the origin of language. W The Evolution of Language. Proceedings of the 10th International Conference (EVOLANG 10), E. A. Cartmill, S. Roberts, H. Cornish, H. Lyn (red.), 266–273. Singapore: World Scientific.

Orzechowski Sylwester, Sławomir Wacewicz, Przemysław Żywiczyński. 2014. Orofacial gestures in language evolution. The auditory feedback hypothesis. W The Evolution of Language. Proceedings of the 10th International Conference (EVOLANG 10), E. A. Cartmill, S. Roberts, H. Cornish, H. Lyn (red.), 221-227. Singapore: World Scientific.

Petitto Laura Ann, Paula F. Marentette. 1991. "Babbling in the Manual Mode: Evidence for the Ontogeny of Language". Science 251 : 1493–1496.

Pika Simone. 2008. What is the nature of the gestural communication of great apes? W The Shared Mind: Perspectives on intersubjectivity, J. Zlatev, T. Racine, C. Sinha, E. Itkonen (red.), 165–186). Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing.

Pika Simone, Katja Liebal. 2006. Differences and similarities between the natural gestural communication of the great apes and human children. W Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on the Evolution of Language (Evolang 6), A. Cangelosi, A. Smith and K. Smith (red.), 267–274. Singapore: World Scientific.

Pika Simone, John C. Mitani. 2009. The directed scratch: Evidence for a referential gesture in chimpanzees? W The prehistory of language, R. Botha, Ch. Knight (red.), 166–180. Oxford University Press.

Pika Simone, Katja Liebal, Josep Call, Michael Tomasello. 2005. "The gestural communication of apes". Gesture 5 : 41–56.

Pinker Steven, Ray Jackendoff. 2005. "The faculty of language: what is special about it?" Cognition 95 : 201–236.

Pollick Amy S., Frans B. M. de Waal. 2007. "Ape gestures and language evolution". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 104 : 8184–8189.

Rizzolatti Giacomo, Michael A. Arbib. 1998. "Language within our grasp". Trends in Neurosciences 21 : 188–194.

Rizzolatti Giacomo, Luciano Fadiga, Leonardo Fogassi, Vittorio Gallese. 1996. "Premotor cortex and the recognition of motor actions". Cognitive brain research 3 : 131–141.

Rowe Meredith L., Susan Goldin-Meadow. 2009. "Early gesture selectively predicts later language learning". Developmental Science 12 : 182–187.

Sandler Wendy. 2013. "Vive la différence: Sign language and spoken language in language evolution". Language and Cognition 5 (2–3) : 189–203.

Stokoe William C. 1960. Sign language structure. Silver Spring: Linstok Press.

Stokoe William C. 1991. "Semantic phonology". Sign language studies 71 : 107–114.

Stokoe William C. 2001. Language in hand: Why sign came before speech. Washington, DC: Gallaudet University Press.

Stokoe William C., Dorothy C. Casterline, Carl G. Croneberg. 1965. A dictionary of American Sign Language on linguistic principles. Silver Spring: Linstok.

Studdert-Kennedy Michael. 2005. How did language go discrete? W Language origins – perspectives on evolution, M. Tallerman (red.), 48–67. Oxford University Press.

Slocombe Katie. 2011. Have we underestimated great ape vocal capacities? W The Oxford Handbook of Language Evolution, K. R. Gibson, M. Tallerman (red.), 90–95. Oxford University Press.

Slocombe Katie, Bridget Waller, Katja Liebal. 2011. "The language void: the need for multimodality in primate communication research". Animal Behaviour 81 (5) : 919–924.

Summerfield A. Quentin. 1992. "Lipreading and audio-visual speech perception". Philosophical Transactions of the royal society B 335 : 71–78.

Sutton-Spence Rachel. 2005. Analysing Sign Language Poetry. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Tallerman Maggie. 2011. Protolanguage. W The Oxford Handbook of Language Evolution, K. R. Gibson, M. Tallerman (red.), 479–491. Oxford University Press.

Tallerman Maggie, Kathleen R. Gibson (red.). 2011. The Oxford handbook of language evolution. Oxford University Press.

Tinbergen Nikolaas. 1951. The study of instinct. New York: Oxford University Press.

Tomasello Michael. 2008. Origins of human communication. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

de Waal Frans B. M., Amy S. Pollick. 2011. Gesture as the most flexible modality of primate communication. W The Oxford handbook of language evolution, K. R. Gibson i M. Tallerman (red.), 82–89. Oxford University Press.

Wacewicz Sławomir. 2008. Ewolucja języka: horyzont metodologiczny. W Metodologie językoznawstwa. Współczesne tendencje i kontrowersje, P. Stalmaszczyk (red.), 27–42. Kraków: Wydawnictwo LEXIS.

Wacewicz Sławomir. 2013. Ewolucja języka – współczesne kontrowersje. W Metodologie językoznawstwa. 1. Ewolucja języka. Ewolucja teorii językoznawczych, P. Stalmaszczyk (red.), 11–26. Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego.

Wacewicz Sławomir, Przemysław Żywiczyński. 2008. Broadcast Transmission, Signal Secrecy And Gestural Primacy Hypothesis. W: A. Smith, K. Smith, R. Ferreri-Cancho (red.), The Evoltuion of Language. Proceedings of the 7th International Conference (EVOLANG 7), 354–361. Singapore: World Scientific.

Zlatev Jordan. 2008. The co-evolution of intersubjectivity and bodily mimesis. W The Shared Mind: Perspectives on intersubjectivity, J. Zlatev, T. Racine, C. Sinha, E. Itkonen (red.), 215–244. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing.

Zlatev Jordan. 2014. Bodily mimesis and the transition to speech. The Evolution of Social Communication in Primates: A Multidisciplinary Approach. O. Pombo, N. Gontier (red.). Berlin: Springer.

Żywiczyński Przemysław, Sławomir Wacewicz. 2008. Ewolucja języka. W stronę hipotez gesturalnych. Toruń: Wydawnictwo Naukowego Uniwersytetu Mikołaja Kopernika.


World Atlas of Linguistic Structures: